Is Remothered good?
Checked . Intent: Compare critic scores before buying.
I wanted one series score and the three games refuse it. The first is a respected mood piece with rough animation. The second is a critical miss with a milder user score. The third is too new to average with them.
PC-facing numbers
Eurogamer Italia, cited by Wikipedia, praised the first game’s atmosphere and criticized the animation. The second game’s write-ups blame bugs, stealth, and a confusing plot.
| Game | Critics | Players |
|---|---|---|
| Tormented Fathers | MC 77 PC, 75 PS4, 68 Xbox, 55 Switch | Steam 75% of 1,782 |
| Broken Porcelain | MC 39 PC, 44 PS4, 49 Xbox; OC 6% recommend | MC users 6.6 of 72 |
| Red Nun's Legacy | MC 71 of 4; OC 74 of 9, 56% recommend | Steam 87% of 32; PSN 4.88 of 26 |
Questions
Which game scored highest?
On PC Metacritic, Tormented Fathers at 77 is above Broken Porcelain at 39. Red Nun’s Legacy at 71 uses only four reviews, so it is not ranked against them as a final score.
Do players match the critics on the second game?
No. Critics are generally unfavorable. Metacritic users are 6.6 from 72 ratings, filed as mixed.
Did the original creator direct the third game?
The wiki says Chris Darril did not develop it. Steam still credits him for the original work. March 2026 reports said he disputed the credit. Those reports were not re-read in full.